During the last few years, Berkshire Hathaway Inc. has made many investments in chemical and chemistry related businesses such as Nalco, Dow (Rohm and Haas), Great Lakes Chemical (GLK), Kaiser Aluminium & Chemical Corp. Sealed Air Corp, GSK, J&J etc. along with some petrochemical companies like ExxonMobile, ConocoPhillips, PetroChina and so on. Mr. Buffet’s notable commitment to the chemical industry is illustrated thorough Monday's announcement to purchase Lubrizol (LZ) for $135 a share, 28% above Friday's closing price! The consummate value investor, Mr. Buffet is expected to pay $9.7bn (which includes $700m in net debt) for the transaction. Even after paying a $30 premium (i.e. 28%) over the $105 closing price on Friday, Lubrizol transaction is priced at approximately, 7x 2011’s EBITDA and 5.4x 2012’s EBITDA.
Now if you consider today’s availability of cheap money in the capital structure, the WACC is no more than 8.5% (assuming at least 2x interest coverage with a realistic leverage 4.7x - 5x), Mr. Buffet is expected to generate top quartile returns (with a minimum Internal Rate of Return (IRR) percentage in the 20s within 3-5 years!).
We can talk all day long about the public market anomalies, various deal dynamics, and business related topics such as sustainability of margins in the lubricant additives value chain or excessive swings of commodity feed stocks (e.g. energy price, oil and petroleum derivatives). However, a company’s success will continue to depend on the management’s ability to control risk and take advantage of perceived market risks. For example, Lubrizol is a well managed company that poses an excellent profile of a “very good” specialty chemical company, growing its revenue consistently (for example: $3.4B in 2004; $5.4 in 2010), generating very strong cash flows and returns on capital, displaying a strong balance-sheet and flush with cash. We should also realize that Lubrizol has been increasing earnings at a compounded growth rate of 16% (at least for last 10 years; and Lubrizol's earnings growth has accelerated to over 25% per annum during the last 5 years).
Lubrizol continues to maintain its specialty status in a “so called commodity risk” environment by focusing on: its proprietary product (not necessarily patent protected product), mastering its product application for their customers’ system/process, delivering process/system monitoring services and maintaining overall strategic focus etc. (note: Relatively speaking, Lubrizol is neither capital intensive nor over reliant on R&D expenditure). Ultimately, Lubrizol’s strong performance over the years coupled with an excellent new owner should position Lubrizol to be even more successful as it moves forward. What are your thoughts?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Both Tronox and Chemtura have been on fire since exiting bankruptcy. With all the Nat Gas finds in the US, and super low gas prices and global growth picking up things look good for Chemicals over the next several years. Good luck
Both Tronox and Chemtura have been on fire since exiting bankruptcy. With all the Nat Gas finds in the US, and super low gas prices and global growth picking up things look good for Chemicals over the next several years. Good luck
Post a Comment